In 2005-06, Union scored a 4.625 average to lead the way.  Union won four sport championships on the season (men's basketball, men's golf, men's and women's cross country), however, only two counted towards the points average.  The two cross country titles didn't count in the total because a sport must have at least four teams to be considered in the All Sports standings.  Union also boasted three runner-up finishes and one third place finish on the season.    Closing the year in a very close second was Trevecca Nazarene at 4.500 who finished behind Union by just 0.125 in the average.  Trevecca Nazarene boasted three titles on the year (men's basketball, softball, and women's golf) of which women's golf didn't count towards the total as the sport didn't meet the four-team minimum. The Trojans also posted two runner-up finishes on the year.   Finishing third was Cumberland at 4.200, fourth was Martin Methodist at 4.050, fifth was Freed-Hardeman at 4.000, and sixth was Lyon at 2.722.  Crichton and Blue Mountain did not meet the minimum of six participating sports to qualify for the All-Sports Trophy.